The Colts spent their 2025 first-round pick on a tight end, which tells you how the offense is being rebuilt. Tyler Warren arrived from Penn State with a reputation as the most versatile player in college football, and No. 84 has been one of the fastest-selling rookie jerseys in Indianapolis since. If you are shopping for a Tyler Warren jersey, this guide covers every version we stock — the blue 2025 draft jersey, the stitched game jersey, the F.U.S.E. throwback and the dark grey Rivalries Collection — plus the fit, sizing and care details worth knowing before you order.
| Version | Colour | Price | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blue 2025 Draft | Colts blue | $69.95 | Fans who want the rookie-year look |
| Blue Football Stitched Game | Colts blue, classic cut | $69.95 | Everyday wear and tailgates |
| Blue F.U.S.E. Throwback Vapor | Blue throwback with patch | $69.95 | Colts history fans and collectors |
| Dark Grey 2026 Rivalries Collection | Charcoal grey, limited run | $69.95 | Fans who want something nobody else has |
Why No. 84 became a Colts jersey worth buying
Warren was the best tight end in college football in 2024, winning the John Mackey Award at Penn State, and he did it in a way that made NFL scouts rethink the position: he lined up at tight end, in the backfield, out wide and even under centre as a wildcat quarterback. Indianapolis drafted him in the first round in 2025 to be a receiving and blocking mismatch in an offense that had been missing exactly that piece.
The jersey follows the role. A tight end who is on the field for nearly every snap, in the red zone and in short-yardage, is a safe bet for a fan — you are not buying a flash player who might disappear from the depth chart, you are buying a player the coaching staff has already built a package around.
Which Tyler Warren jersey should you buy?
All four styles below are stitched and priced the same, so pick by colour and by how you plan to wear it.
Blue is the Colts colour. Indianapolis wears blue at home, and the blue 2025 draft jersey is the closest match to what Warren wore in his first NFL season — rookie-year styling with the draft detailing collectors look for. If you are buying one Warren jersey, this is the safe pick.
The stitched game jersey is the workhorse. Same blue, classic cut, built for tailgates and Sunday wear. Choose it if you want a looser fit than the tighter F.U.S.E. cut.
The F.U.S.E. throwback is for Indianapolis history fans. A blue throwback silhouette with the commemorative patch edition, the jersey that pairs best with an Andrew Luck or Peyton Manning throwback in the same closet.
The dark grey 2026 Rivalries Collection is the limited one. Charcoal grey instead of blue, produced in a limited run — the pick if you would rather not wear the same jersey as everyone else in your section.
Indianapolis Colts #84 Tyler Warren Blue 2025 F.U.S.E. Throwback Vapor Limited Jersey
$69.95
Shop Now →What number does Tyler Warren wear for the Indianapolis Colts?
Tyler Warren wears No. 84 for the Indianapolis Colts. He is the tight end Indianapolis selected in the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft out of Penn State, where he won the John Mackey Award as the best tight end in college football and also lined up at quarterback, running back and receiver. No. 84 is the number stitched on every Warren jersey we stock — the blue 2025 draft jersey, the blue football stitched game jersey, the blue F.U.S.E. throwback vapor limited and the dark grey 2026 Rivalries Collection limited. At Penn State he wore No. 44, which is why our college-style listing carries 44 instead of 84. The rule when you order is the same either way: the number in the product title is the number printed on the jersey. Every Colts style here is stitched, in stock, and ships from US warehouses in about 5-8 business days with tracking.
Indianapolis Colts #84 Tyler Warren Dark Gray 2026 F.U.S.E. Rivalries Collection Limited Jersey
$69.95
Shop Now →Fit, sizing and care for a tight end jersey
Tight ends wear the most forgiving jersey in football, and these cuts follow that. The stitched game jersey runs true to a standard athletic fit — order your normal shirt size. The F.U.S.E. vapor cut is slightly trimmer through the chest and shoulders, so if you are between sizes, size up. For anyone layering a hoodie underneath in December, the game jersey is the easier choice.
Care is what keeps the stitching and the patch looking new: turn the jersey inside out, wash cold on a delicate cycle, and hang it to dry. Skip the dryer entirely — heat is what cracks a stitched number over time. Never iron directly on the numbers, nameplate or patch, and store the jersey on a wide hanger so the shoulders do not crease. Keep it out of long direct sunlight, which fades blue faster than fans expect.
Game day styling and where to keep shopping
Colts blue is easy to style: dark jeans or chinos, white sneakers, and a blue or white cap. The dark grey limited edition is the one that calls for a quieter outfit — black jeans and a plain shirt so the jersey carries the look. For cold games at Lucas Oil Stadium, layer a hoodie underneath the jersey rather than over it to keep the number visible.
Every colourway above is in our Indianapolis Colts jersey collection, and if you are building a Colts set we already have guides for the Andrew Luck jersey, the Anthony Richardson jersey and the Jonathan Taylor jersey. For the wider league picture, start from our football jersey hub.
Is a Tyler Warren jersey true to size?
Yes. The stitched game jersey runs true to a standard athletic fit, and the F.U.S.E. vapor cut is slightly trimmer — size up if you are between sizes or layering a hoodie.
Are the numbers stitched or printed?
Every edition in this guide is stitched, including the numbers, nameplate and shoulder details. A heat-pressed jersey would be labelled as such in the product title.
Does Warren wear No. 84 or No. 44?
No. 84 is his Indianapolis Colts number. No. 44 is the Penn State number from his college career, used on our college-style listing — check the title before ordering.
How long does shipping take?
US orders usually arrive in 5-8 business days, with tracked express options at checkout if you need it sooner.
Rookie jerseys are the ones that age best: buy the season a player arrives, and you own the first chapter. Warren is locked into a big role in Indianapolis, so pick your colourway and size while the 2025 styles are still in stock.
