Few quarterbacks left Indianapolis with a legacy as complicated and beloved as Andrew Luck. Drafted #1 overall in 2012 to replace Peyton Manning — no small task — Luck spent seven seasons throwing the Colts into the playoffs four times before a shocking retirement in 2018 that still gets debated on sports radio. For collectors and lifelong Colts fans, the Andrew Luck jersey remains one of the most requested throwback pieces in the shop, and it's easy to see why: the #12 blue-and-white kit represents an era of Colts football that felt genuinely exciting again after the Manning years.
If you're browsing our lineup, you'll notice the Luck jerseys come in more variety than most single-player collections — FUSE editions, the 40th Anniversary patch version, and the Elite Pro Line Gold Collection all show up in different colorways. Here's a quick breakdown to help you choose.
| Version | Color/Style | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 FUSE 40th Anniversary | Blue | $69.95 | Fans who want the commemorative patch |
| 2023 FUSE Home/Away | Blue or White | $69.95 | Everyday game-day wear |
| Elite Pro Line Gold Collection | Black | $69.95 | Collectors who want a standout alternate |
| Gridiron Gray | Gray | $69.95 | Something different from the usual blue/white |
The Andrew Luck Legacy in Indianapolis
Luck's rookie-to-retirement arc is one of the more unusual stories in modern NFL history. He put up 4,000+ passing yards in three of his first four seasons, made the Pro Bowl four times, and dragged some genuinely undertalented Colts rosters into the postseason through sheer arm talent and toughness. Wearing an andrew luck colts jersey today is as much a nod to that grit as it is team pride — this was a guy who played through injuries most starters would have shut down for.
Choosing Between the Blue, White, and Alternate Colorways
Blue is the classic pick and the one you'll see most in the stands at Lucas Oil Stadium — it's the primary home jersey color and reads well in photos. White is the road version and tends to look cleaner paired with jeans for a casual fit. If you want something that stands out from the usual crowd, the black Elite Pro Line Gold Collection or the Gridiron Gray options are worth a look; they're less common so you won't see three other people wearing the same thing at a tailgate.
Sizing and Fit Tips
These are stitched replica jerseys cut in the same athletic fit as the on-field version, which runs a little roomier than a standard tee. If you're between sizes or plan to layer a hoodie underneath on cold December Sundays, size up one. Kids and youth builds fit true to size — check the size chart on each product page before ordering, especially if this is a birthday or holiday gift.
Building a Colts Game Day Fit
Pair the jersey with navy or white joggers and Colts-branded accessories for a clean, non-costume-y look. If you already collect other Colts eras, the Anthony Richardson jersey makes a fun modern-meets-classic pairing when you want to rotate looks, and long-time fans often stack the Luck jersey next to a Quenton Nelson jersey to represent both the passing game and the offensive line that protected it.
For the full current lineup of Colts gear beyond single-player pieces, browse the Indianapolis Colts collection.
Is this an authentic on-field jersey or a replica?
These are stitched replica jerseys — numbers, names, and logos are sewn on, not printed, so they hold up to regular wear and washing.
What size should I order?
Fits true to athletic sizing; size up one if you plan to layer underneath. Full size charts are on each product page.
Can I wash it like a regular jersey?
Yes — cold wash, hang dry. Avoid the dryer to protect the stitched lettering and patches.
Do you offer returns if the size doesn't work out?
Yes, standard return policy applies within the window listed on our Refund & Return page — just keep tags attached.
Whether you're reliving the 2012 draft-day excitement or just want a #12 jersey that isn't the same one everyone else at the tailgate is wearing, the Andrew Luck collection has a colorway for it. Shop the full range above or check out the rest of the Colts jerseys collection for more.
